Be part of JetBrains PHPverse 2026 on June 9 – a free online event bringing PHP devs worldwide together.
"data": [
{
"username": "Sigurd Homenick",
"body": "Et repudiandae corporis quam modi.
},
{
"username": "Homenick",
"body": "Et r213epudiandae corporis quam modi.
}
],
What is appropriate position of comments_count in API Resources ? I would like to put in direct key of data wrapper and access it on view like $json['data']['comments_count']
But i have two problem,
If i use collection method i can not add any additional meta data into json,
So i tried CommnetCollection instead in order to add aditional meta data
public function show(Thread $thread)
{
return new CommentsCollection(
$thread->comments
);
}
class CommentsCollection extends ResourceCollection
{
/**
* Transform the resource collection into an array.
*
* @param \Illuminate\Http\Request $request
* @return array
*/
public function toArray($request)
{
return [
'data' => CommentsResource::collection($this->collection),
'comments_count' => $this->collection->first()->commentable->comments_count
];
}
}
But in this scenario comments_count is outside of data wrapper and if add it to CommentResource it shows comments_count on every comment array i want it included in data key but not in all array inside of it just like this : $json['data']['comments_count']
@untymage and have you tried it this way?
return [
'data' => [
CommentsResource::collection($this->collection),
'comments_count' => $this->collection->first()->commentable->comments_count
],
];
Or try to push it to the collection returned by the resource:
CommentsResource::collection($this->collection)
->push('comments_count',
$this->collection->first()->commentable->comments_count),
@nakov thanks it worked (Why it never came to my mind 😬)
@nakov I realized that when using CommentsResource inside of data key the output have extra 0 key on each array:
[{
"data": {
"0": [
{
"username": "Prof. Millie Bailey",
"body": "Explicabo laudantium ut
}
],
"comments_count": 1
}
}]
Why is that? how to remove it
@untymage because CommentResource returns a collection, and now the data is an array as well.
Have you tried both versions that I've shared?
What about using this:
return [
'data' => CommentsResource::collection($this->collection)->push('comments_count', $this->collection->first()->commentable->comments_count),
];
Ok, But look at this:
I have two extra key that i mark in the image, first is for data key and second is around comments array
$json[0]['data'] and $json[0]['data'][0][0] I dont like this mess xD
I don't like that neither but do you have just this now
public function toArray($request)
{
return [
'data' => CommentsResource::collection($this->collection)->push('comments_count', $this->collection->first()->commentable->comments_count),
];
}
and it produces that weird result?
Done, Now is better :
If we could remove that 0 around the data key ......... :d
@untymage now the problem is within your CommentResource.. maybe you just need to use that one.. or try this instead
public function toArray($request)
{
return CommentsResource::collection($this->collection)->push('comments_count', $this->collection->first()->commentable->comments_count);
}
One thing, push method takes one param, Do you meanput in all your replies right?
Then you won't need the extra resource that you use, and you can add in each item of the CommentResource.. But that doesn't make sense. As you need the total count once..
Please or to participate in this conversation.