I'm doing some user testing to find out which of the below options makes most sense.. Would appreciate your feedback ♥
Which option makes more sense to you?
NOTE: In all below options only one of the buttons will be shown at any time (they will toggle). I have put them in the same image just to demonstrate both states.
Option A
Button TEXT shows the state that will happen when pressed.
Button COLOR shows the state that will happen when pressed.
Option B
Button TEXT shows the state that will happen when pressed.
I'd go for Option C, option A is second but its not clear I mean it doesn't sound like an action, its more like a state unless you add some blur effect
Each button will show separately, I just put them together so I could demonstrate both states in one image. I have updated the OP and put a notice about it.
@SaeedPrez It’s still jarring from a UX point of view. If I see a red button with a label ‘Inactive’, I don’t know whether that represents the item’s current state, or the state if I were to click it.
Instead. Consider a “switch” where it’s apparent what the current state is, and what sliding it will do:
In my opinion, activate should e green and deactivate should be red. But it depends on what youre deactivating. If its not anything critical, I would just use a minor color for it. Or, because you can only deactivate something that is active in the first place, and vice versa, grey out the one that is irrelevant.
Just to say, I've recently had to re-do some code that showed similar-ish states to be more accessibility friendly. So I need to make sure there is clear text (or at least an indication of which side a toggle is on/off) to indicate the state and not relying on colour or just the position of a button/slider. You're maybe already doing that - but thought it was worth pointing out :-)
I was sat with a user who has very low vision and uses a b&w display to help - it was a bit of a revelation how un-clear my app became... :-/ This page has something like the on/off I ended up with :
Thanks @ohffs those look very nice. I've bookmarked it for the future. In this project I need links (buttons) so I ended up redesigning what I had to this.