2 Domains | 1 IP - NGINX

I have two domains on D.O set up through forge on the same server/IP, both have been active for 4 months and issue-free. https://lightpointdev.com and https://jlsdesk.com.

Originally before moving them, they were on shared cloud hosting at Bluehost which I configured to point to D.O nameservers. When the hosting plan at Bluehost ended https://jlsdesk.com (which was the primary Bluehost domain) no longer loads but gives me a non-descript error, https://lightpointdev.com still works correctly.

I have checked the nginx configs and both sites have a vhost in the config specifying their server name as :

server {
    listen xxx ssl http2;
    listen [::]:xxx ssl http2;
    server_name jlsdesk.com;
    root /xxx/xxx/jlsdesk.com/public;

and

server {
    listen xxx ssl http2;
    listen [::]:xxx ssl http2;
    server_name lightpointdev.com;
    root /xxx/xxx/lightpointdev.com/public;

I see no changes that have taken place with the exception that over on D.O under networking / Domains these two domains now show "multiple locations" in the Directs to column rather than the server name and ip address.

The nameservers are correct...the A Types are lightpointdev.com/www.lightpointdev.com | jlsdesk.com/www.jlsdesk.com the value is the correct ip . It seems as if everything should be ok. Everything is active, DNS records are published and I've verified everything that I know to do.

Am I missing a configuration I need that would replace something Bluehost did for jlsdesk.com?

Thank you in advance.