Socialite InvalidStateException - but only when logging in with the 3rd party first

This is for a traditional app, not a SPA

I'm getting an Laravel \ Socialite \ Two \ InvalidStateException error when logging in via socialite github provider - but only when I have to login to github during the process.

1. myapp.com/login
2. login with github button
3. actually log into github
4. automatically redirected back to my /callback and get the error

If I'm logged in to github prior to starting the process it works fine.

1. myapp.com/login
2. login with github button
3. automatically redirected back to my /callback and logged in (or well got the success at least)

I use 1password so the github login process with user/pw and 2fa is pretty quick, like a second or 2. Anyone know why this would cause socialte to fail?

  public function redirectToGithub() {
    return Socialite::driver('github')->redirect();
  }

  public function handleGithubCallback() {
    //try {
      $oathUser = Socialite::driver('github')->user();
      dd($oathUser);
      $localUser = User::where('email', $oathUser->getEmail())->get()->first();
      if (!$localUser) {
        return view('auth.user-not-found');
      }
      else {
        Auth::login($localUser);
        return redirect($this->redirectTo);
      }
    //}
//    catch (Exception $exception) {
//      dump($exception->getMessage());
//      dd($exception);
//      return view('auth.oauth-error');
//    }
  }