Be part of JetBrains PHPverse 2026 on June 9 – a free online event bringing PHP devs worldwide together.

ramniksingh's avatar

Running a query multiple times inside foreach loop and storing the results in an array.

Hello Everyone, I have encountered a strange problem. I am trying to run a query multiple times with foreach loop and storing the results in an array to use later for some calculations.

Below is the detail:

This works

$test = DB::table('appcal')
                    ->select('monthyear','appdate')
                    ->whereDate('appdate','>=', '2018-04-01')
                    ->get();

        dd($test);

But this does not work

foreach($activities as $activity){
            $qry[] = DB::table('appcal')
                    ->select('monthyear','appdate')
                    ->whereDate('appdate','>=', '2018-04-01')
                    ->get(); 
        }
            dd($qry);

But this work

foreach($activities as $activity){
            $qry[] = DB::table('appcal')
                    ->select('monthyear','appdate')
                    ->whereDate('appdate','=', '2018-04-01')
                    ->get(); 
        }
            dd($qry);

Can you suggest what is the issue here? Am I doing something wrong ?

What should I correctly do to store the query results in an array to use later for some calculations.

0 likes
5 replies
martinbean's avatar

I am trying to run a query multiple times with foreach loop

@ramniksingh Don’t 😬 That’s the very definition of the N+1 problem.

ramniksingh's avatar

Thanks. I have read about N+1 and solving this with some other method either with join or eager loading.

But What is happening here? Why is it presents different behaviour. It should have run despite being slow. Is there some memory issue?

And I think it will easily run in traditional php in comparison to laravel framework.

Snapey's avatar

But this query will give you identical result on every iteration

Please or to participate in this conversation.